If you live in Florida, you’ve probably seen that most backyard pools are inside large screened enclosures, often called pool cages. These are a common part of life here.

But not every homeowner chooses to install one. In fact, many people investing in custom inground pools or custom pools are now removing enclosures to create a more open, resort-style outdoor living space.

So, which option is best for your home?

The answer depends on what matters most to you—maintenance, looks, budget, and how you want to use your pool. Whether you’re designing a new pool or updating an old one, knowing the pros and cons of screened enclosures and open pools can help you decide.

The Benefits of a Screen Enclosure for Your Custom-Designed Pool

Protection From Bugs, Debris, and Wildlife

One of the main benefits of a screened enclosure is protection. Screens help keep out:

  • Leaves and yard debris
  • Pollen and dust
  • Mosquitoes and insects
  • Birds and neighborhood animals

In Florida’s warm climate, where mosquitoes are common, this can make spending time outside much more enjoyable. If you live near lakes, woods, or preserves, a screen enclosure gives you peace of mind by creating a barrier between your pool and local wildlife.

Easier Pool Maintenance

With less debris in the water, you’ll have less work to do. Pools inside screened enclosures typically require:

  • Leaves and yard debris
  • Pollen and dust
  • Mosquitoes and insects
  • Birds and neighborhood animals

Over time, this can make your pool easier and cheaper to maintain. Many pool companies near me recommend enclosures for homeowners who want a lower-maintenance pool experience.

Extended Swimming Season

If you add a pool heater, a screen enclosure helps keep the water warm and blocks some wind. It also gives light protection from rain, so you can use your pool more often all year. For families investing in custom inground pools, this added usability can make the investment even more worthwhile.

Sun and UV Protection

Florida sunshine can be strong. The screen mesh filters some UV rays but still lets in lots of natural light. This helps protect your skin from too much sun, making pool time more comfortable for kids and anyone sensitive to sunlight.

Wind Resistance by Design

Modern pool enclosures are engineered with Florida weather in mind. Many structures are rated to withstand winds of up to 130 mph. While they aren’t hurricane-proof, they are designed to handle typical storm conditions in the region.

The Downsides of Screen Enclosures

Despite the benefits, screened enclosures come with several trade-offs homeowners should consider when designing their custom-designed pool.

High Installation Cost

A new enclosure can cost between $15,000 and $25,000 or more, depending on its size and design. If you’re already building a custom inground pool, this can add a lot to your total budget.

Ongoing Maintenance and Repairs

Screens and frames require upkeep over time. Common maintenance issues include:

  • Torn or damaged mesh panels
  • Pressure washing to remove mold or mildew
  • Frame cleaning or repainting
  • Storm damage repairs

Replacing large panels can be costly because of the height and extra work involved.

Storm Vulnerability

Even though they’re made to resist wind, enclosures can still get badly damaged during hurricanes or strong storms.
Repairs or full replacements after a storm can be costly, which is why some homeowners working with pool builders near me choose to skip the enclosure entirely.

Cooler Pool Water

Since the mesh blocks some sunlight, pools inside enclosures often warm up more slowly and can stay cooler in spring and fall. This might mean higher heating costs if you like your pool water warm.

The “Cage” Effect

A common complaint is how the enclosure looks. Screen enclosures can make a backyard feel:

  • Smaller
  • More enclosed
  • Less connected to nature

For homeowners investing in custom backyard pools, aesthetics often play a major role in deciding whether to include an enclosure.

The Advantages of an Open Pool (No Screen Enclosure)

Choosing an open pool gives you a very different backyard experience.

Many homeowners working with pool companies near me are now opting for open designs to create a luxury outdoor living environment.

Resort-Style Atmosphere

Without the aluminum frame and mesh above, your pool area can feel more like a luxury resort. The space looks bigger, more open, and blends better with your landscaping. This style is especially popular for custom pools made for entertaining and outdoor living.

Unobstructed Views

If you have a water view, woods, or a landscaped yard, an open pool keeps your view clear. There’s nothing blocking your view from frames or screens.

Better Airflow and Comfort

Screens can block breezes, which sometimes makes pool decks feel warmer or stuffy. Open pools let the air flow freely, so it feels cooler and more refreshing in the summer.

Naturally Warmer Pool Water

Direct sunlight warms the water faster and keeps it warmer for more of the year. This means you may not need the pool heater as much, which can save money.

Lower Long-Term Costs

Not adding a screen enclosure can save you thousands of dollars up front and cut out future maintenance costs. If you’re building a custom inground pool, you can put more of your budget toward features like:

For homeowners investing in custom backyard pools, aesthetics often play a major role in deciding whether to include an enclosure.

More Recreational Freedom

Open pool spaces allow activities like:

  • Pool basketball

  • Tossing balls

  • Floating games

You don’t have to worry about hitting or damaging anything above you.

Greater Landscaping Freedom

Without enclosure height restrictions, you can plant:

  • Tall palms
  • Tropical gardens
  • Decorative trees

This lets your custom backyard pool blend right into a lush outdoor setting.

Florida Pool Safety Requirements

  • Safety fences
  • Self-closing, self-latching gates
  • Pool alarms

Professional pool builders near me can ensure your pool design meets all state safety requirements.

Which Pool Design Is Right for You?

There’s no universal “best” choice, only what fits your lifestyle.

A Screen Enclosure May Be Ideal If You:

  • Want fewer bugs and debris
  • Prefer easier maintenance
  • Live near water or wooded areas
  • Want shaded swimming
  • Value protection and convenience

An Open Pool May Be Better If You:

  • Want a luxury, resort-style look
  • Love sun exposure and warmer water

  • Prefer unobstructed backyard views

  • Want to avoid enclosure costs

  • Enjoy flexible landscaping design

The Takeaway

Screened enclosures are still popular in Florida because they offer comfort, cleanliness, and protection. But they also come with extra costs, maintenance, and some trade-offs in how your backyard looks. Open pools give you more beauty, warmth, and freedom, but you may need to clean more often and deal with more bugs.

In the end, the best choice depends on how you want your backyard to feel and how you’ll use your pool every day.

Ready to Design Your Dream Pool?

If you’re searching for pool builders near me or looking for pool companies near me that specialize in custom inground pools and custom backyard pools, our team can help bring your vision to life.

From custom pools to full outdoor living spaces, we design pools that fit your lifestyle and property. Contact us today to set up a consultation and start planning the backyard you’ve always wanted.